Tempur-Pedic vs Saatva (2021): Comparing Two of the Most Popular Mattress Brands in the Market

Tempur-Pedic and Saatva are two mattress brands that have established a solid reputation in the industry. Both have had their share of glowing reviews just about anywhere you look online, thanks to the outstanding quality of their products.

While both are reliable, it’s not a stretch to say you’ll get a vastly different experience out of each one. Tempur-Pedic mattresses are expensive, but their quality is on another level, often coming with tons of sleeping technologies. Meanwhile, Saatva mattresses are known for being luxurious yet affordable with a more traditional construction. At that, we compare the two to help you find out what you can expect from each one.

Tempur-Pedic vs Saatva Comparison Chart

Name	Tempur-Pedic	Saatva
	Amazon product
Price	Amazon product	Check Price at SaatvaMattress.com
Firmness Levels	Soft, medium, medium hybrid, firm	Plush soft, firm, luxury firm
Sizes	Twin, Twin Long, Double, Queen, King, Split King, CA King, Split CA King	Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King, Split Cal King
Material	Memory foam-based TEMPUR Material	Innerspring, memory foam
Profile Range	10 to 13 inches	11.5 to 14.5 inches
CertiPUR-US Certification	Yes	Yes
White Glove Delivery	Free	Free
Sleep Trial	Yes, 90 days	Yes, 180 days
Warranty	10 years	15 years

Mattress Construction

Only Tempur-Pedic has mattresses constructed without innersprings.

When choosing between Tempur-Pedic and Saatva, you’re pretty much deciding between memory foam and spring mattresses. Tempur-Pedic mainly uses memory foam for its products—or to be exact, TEMPUR Material. Saatva goes primarily with innersprings, and in fact, it’s arguably among the best manufacturers that use this traditional construction. That’s coupled with a touch of memory foam for pressure relief and a Euro pillow top, the cushioning of which is considered to be better than standard counterparts.

Now that that’s cleared up, you’ll get a more even pressure distribution and minimal motion transfer, as well as that slow sinking feel typical of memory foams with Tempur-Pedic. In comparison, you’ll get a more “usual” feel with better responsiveness and more bounce with Saatva.

Speaking of, Tempur-Pedic also has a medium hybrid option that adds over 1,000 spring coils to the mix, if a bit more bounce is what you’re after. Basically, this is similar to Saatva’s mattress.

The takeaway here is to decide whether you prefer a memory foam or innerspring mattress first before thinking about which brand to go with.

Mattress Types

Tempur-Pedic has more options to choose from.

Both have all the standard sizes you can think of, from Twin and Queen to King and CA King. They also have similar offerings of firmness levels. First off, Tempur-Pedic has soft, medium, the aforementioned medium hybrid, and firm. Saatva has three in store: plush soft, luxury firm, and firm.

Now this is where Tempur-Pedic stands out. It has a range of mattress models made for all sorts of sleepers. For starters, there’s the TEMPUR-Cloud, TEMPUR-Adapt, TEMPUR-ProAdapt, and TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt, and then there’s the top-of-the-line TEMPUR-breeze. Each one packs unique sleeping features. For instance, the TEMPUR-Cloud is the vanilla variant with the most affordable price, and the Adapt series focuses on providing optimal support.

Just to preface this, one common problem for memory foams is heat retention. However, Tempur-Pedic not only uses breathable material to minimize that, but it also takes other measures to alleviate it further. That’s where the TEMPUR-breeze comes in. It has advanced cooling technologies called PRObreeze and LUXEbreeze, keeping things cooler by up to 3°F or 8°F, respectively.

While Saatva only offers one model, it does have an advantage compared to Tempur-Pedic because of that: Buyers have a more straightforward experience in getting a mattress. That’s a pretty stark contrast when purchasing a mattress from Tempur-Pedic since their options may get overwhelming. You might even end up spending hours comparing models and thinking it over again and again before making a decision. But hey, it could be argued that that’s time well spent because a mattress is a huge investment.

Pricing and Availability

Saatva mattresses give you more bang for the buck.

Right off the bat, Tempur-Pedic is pricier by a mile than Saatva. After all, it can go up to three times more expensive, depending on the model.

That’s because Tempur-Pedic is considered as one of the pioneers of memory foam mattresses. In a way, it has the authority to set relatively exorbitant prices. On top of that, its products are primarily available from retailers, and that inevitably includes markups and such.

On that note, Saatva is only available online. That effectively takes the middleman out of the picture, allowing the company to do business directly with buyers. Needless to say, that allows it to keep prices down.

As for the pros, you can see for yourself how a Tempur-Pedic mattress feels like firsthand at a brick-and-mortar store before making a purchase. On the other hand, you’ll have to have faith in a Saatva mattress’s quality, but that’s a nonissue anyway since the brand only has one model, as well as a long sleep trial and warranty (more on that in a bit). You’ll have to know your stuff when it comes to firmness and size if you want to get it right the first time, though.

Other Considerations

Both brands have a CertiPUR-US certification.

Both offer the usual, such as night trials, long warranties, and free white glove delivery. However, Saatva beats Tempur-Pedic across the board here.

To start things off, Tempur-Pedic gives a 90-day sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty on its products. Saatva ups the ante with a sleep trial of 180 days and a 15-year guarantee.

Moreover, Saatva uses eco-friendly materials for its products, so if protecting the environment is a cause that matters to you, then you’re in luck. That said, it uses organic cotton for its covers, recycled steel for its innersprings, and CertiPUR-US memory foam, meaning it’s made without certain harmful chemicals. For the record, Tempur-Pedic mattresses also have a CertiPUR-US certification.

Verdict

Tempur-Pedic offers more options and features, while Saatva makes things a whole lot simpler, which says a lot.

There’s no clear winner here, and really, what you should look for is a mattress that suits your sleeping habits to help you get a good night’s rest, regardless of the brand.

But objectively speaking, Tempur-Pedic has all sorts of products with unique sleeping technologies, making sure it has a mattress for any type of sleeper, but it’s on the expensive side. Saatva offers a no-frills experience in comparison, and its mattresses have better value for money since their pricing model cuts out retailers and markups.

FAQs