Tempur-Pedic remains one of the most sought-after brands in the bedding industry ever since it popularized the use of memory foam in mattresses. Nonetheless, the luxury brand isn’t without competition. Companies like Amerisleep boast of similar memory foam mattresses but at a more affordable, albeit still expensive, price point. Given their similarities, is Amerisleep simply a “budget” alternative or does it hold its own against industry pillars like Tempur-Pedic? Read our comparison below to find out.
Tempur-Pedic vs Amerisleep Comparison Chart
|Amazon product||Amazon product|
|Price||Amazon product||Amazon product|
|Sizes||Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King, Split Cal King||Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King|
|Profile Range||10 to 14 inches||10 to 14 inches|
|Available Feels||Soft, Medium, Medium Hybrid, Firm||Soft, Medium Soft, Medium, Medium Firm, Firm|
|Free Shipping||Yes, within the continental US||Yes, within the continental US|
|Sleep Trial||90-night sleep trial||100-night sleep trial|
|Warranty||10 years||The first 10 years is a full replacement warranty; the second 10 years is a prorated warranty|
Between Tempur-Pedic and Amerisleep is an extensive catalog of all-foam and hybrid mattresses.
Consumers vary in their sleeping habits and preferences, pushing mattress brands to truly expand their lineup of products. This holds true for both Tempur-Pedic and Amerisleep.
Tempur-Pedic’s catalog includes entry-level mattresses like the TEMPUR-Cloud, as well as specially-designed beds for hot sleepers. For instance, its TEMPUR-breeze collection, featuring LUXEbreeze and PROBreeze beds, incorporate breathable layers to combat heat issues that typically plague memory foam mattresses. Both the LUXEbreeze and PRObreeze are also the most expensive models you can get from the brand.
Meanwhile, those looking for either comfort or pressure relief can choose from TEMPUR-Adapt, ProAdapt, and LuxeAdapt. Across these three mattress models, sleepers will find varying thicknesses of tempur used in their support layers.
Amerisleep takes a simpler approach when it comes to their catalog. The brand’s lineup of mattresses is named matter-of-factly: AS1, AS2, AS3, AS4, and AS5. All models come with the company’s Bio-Pur memory foam, although the AS5 and AS4 are undoubtedly Amerisleep’s most premium offerings. If you’re on a budget, then the AS1, AS2, and AS3’s twin-size beds all come under $1,000.
Just like Tempur-Pedic, Amerisleep also offers all-foam and hybrid versions of their beds. However, not all models do. The same applies to Tempur-Pedic — Cloud, LuxeAdapt, and LUXEbreeze are only available purely in memory foam. Amerisleep, on the other hand, limits hybrid variants to AS2, AS3, and AS5.
Design and Construction
Both mattress brands use innovative materials in their layered-construction.
Memory foam mattresses are all about layers. This construction method lends these beds the strength, durability, and responsiveness it aims to deliver. Both Tempur-Pedic and Amerisleep primarily employ a layered construction, although their respective hybrid models incorporate coils for added bounce and support.
Now, the luxurious, slow-sinking memory foam of Tempur-Pedic mattresses has largely defined what the brand is all about. Across its catalog, the company’s mattresses all feature its innovative high-density tempur polyfoam. The material was initially developed by NASA but has since then been popularized as a vital component of these high-end beds.
There are variations of the memory foam of course, with the original formula used only by the TEMPUR-Adapt model. But the general construction of Tempur-Pedic mattresses roughly follows the same direction.
A premium foam layer makes up the base of the beds, providing durability and strength. Support and comfort layers are then added, with the former designed for pressure relief while the latter is crucial to the responsiveness of the mattress. With hybrid variants, the mattresses make use of 1,000 premium spring coils encased in polyfoam
Covers will vary. Breeze mattresses typically feature phase change material or breathable comfort layers to aid in airflow. Meanwhile, the standard models either get a dual cover system, cool-to-touch cover or moisture-wicking cover.
Amerisleep follows a three-layer construction method that’s not too different from Tempur-Pedic’s. There’s a base support layer that helps prevent sagging. There is also a comfort layer on top to cushion a sleeper’s body. However, that’s largely where the similarities end between the brand’s hybrid and all-foam models.
Amerisleep’s memory foam mattresses, which it calls Affinity with HIVE, use a responsive foam layer as its transition layer. This foam helps create zoned support for sleepers. In contrast, the hybrid variants make use of pocketed coils for added bounce, improved airflow, and better motion isolation.
You do get some extra features with the AS5 mattress. Apart from the transition layer, the model included Amerisleep’s proprietary Active Flex foam for enhanced softness while also adding support and preventing sinkage. If you opt for the entry-level AS1, on the other hand, you’ll only get a slightly thicker base layer and the standard Bio-Pur comfort layer.
Tempur-Pedic is great in motion isolation, contouring, and pressure relief while Amerisleep fares better in firmness and support.
If you like that sinking feeling in the bed, then you’ll love Tempur-Pedic. While there are options for a firmer variant, the company’s mattresses typically offer excellent body contouring. This is great if you’re a side sleeper who prefers consistent pressure relief, especially on your hips and shoulders.
Sleepers who share bed space will also appreciate the impressive motion isolation of Tempur-Pedic mattresses. Because of the high-density foam used, it’s easier to toss and turn around the bed without worrying about waking up your partner. Edge support is a little iffy, as with all memory foam mattresses. But if you do want a bit more bounce, there is a hybrid option.
Amerisleep mattresses, on the other hand, feel a lot firmer. Still, actual performance will vary across the models and on the type of sleeper you are. The closest you can get to really sinking into a bed will be the AS5 mattress, which boasts of the Active Flex layer. For combination sleepers, however, the AS3 strikes the right balance between comfort and support. But if you’re a strict side sleeper, you might prefer the AS4 and AS5.
Customers share that with Amerisleep, you do feel more “on top” of the mattress compared to similar memory foam brands. So if you’re after comfort, you might prefer Tempur-Pedic’s lineup instead.
Amerisleep memory foam and hybrid mattresses are less expensive than Tempur-Pedic across all bed sizes.
Aside from construction and feel, Tempur-Pedic and Amerisleep greatly differ in pricing. Tempur-Pedic is a premium brand with an entry-level twin-size mattress that will set you back almost $1,700. Meanwhile, the brand’s most expensive offering is the LUXEbreeze, which comes in at $4,999. Hybrid variants typically cost more than their all-foam counterparts.
Amerisleep is less expensive across all sizes. However, it still doesn’t come cheap. The AS1 memory foam option costs $899, while the hybrid model is priced at $1,119. If you want Amerisleep’s most comforting mattress — the AS5 — prepare to shell out at least $1,849 for a twin-size bed and $3,798 for a split-king. The hybrid AS5, on the other hand, is regularly priced at over $4,000.
Amerisleep is less expensive and is better suited for combo sleepers. Tempur-Pedic, on the other hand, is great for those who want superior comfort and pressure relief.Amazon product
Tempur-Pedic and Amerisleep are a cut above regular mattresses. Both brands make use of their respective proprietary foam material and offer a range of models to suit different types of sleepers.
Sleepers with deep pockets may want to consider investing in a Tempur-Pedic. The brand’s luxury mattresses are tried-and-tested and have long been a hallmark of the bedding industry. It’s not for all sleepers, however. Those who prefer firm back support or who sleep on their stomach will probably find Tempur-Pedic too comforting. Side sleepers and couples who share a bed are bound to benefit the most from the brand’s unique mattress feel.
Meanwhile, those who want to try out memory foam mattresses without spending too much can take a look into Amerisleep. The company’s beds are firmer than Tempur-Pedic’s, making them a reasonable option for combination sleepers. It offers great back support, too, although the comfort layer doesn’t cushion as much as other brands. Still, Amerisleep’s construction is pretty solid given its pricing across different bed sizes. For that first foray into memory foam beds, the brand is a great choice.
Tempur-Pedic and Amerisleep mattresses are manufactured in the US.
Tempur-Pedic mattresses make use of tempur, a high-density polyfoam originally developed by NASA. Meanwhile, Amerisleep calls its foam Bio-Pur, which is made from plant-based materials.
No, Tempur Pedic’s LuxeAdapt only comes in an all-foam model
Amerisleep’s AS5 mattress has the thickest comfort layers, making it more suitable for side sleepers who like to sink into the bed. For back sleepers, Amerisleep’s AS3 is the best mattress to get.