We are reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Tempur-Pedic vs Sealy (2020): Which Mattress Brand Is Better?

Comparing Tempur-Pedic and Sealy is always an interesting affair. Both were rivals in the bedding industry before Tempur-Pedic acquired Sealy back in 2012. But while the mattress brands are now under the same roof, there are key differences between the two. Sealy, for instance, is far less expensive compared to its luxury sibling. Moreover, the brand is more popular for its innerspring mattresses compared to Tempur-Pedic’s memory foam models. But is that all there is to it? Below, we compare the two mattress brands to help you choose what’s best for your sleep.

Tempur-Pedic vs Sealy Comparison Chart

ModelTempur-PedicSealy
 Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt 11-Inch Medium Foam Mattress, Queen, Made in USA, 10 Year WarrantySealy 12-Inch Hybrid Bed in a Box with CopperChill, Medium, Queen
PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
Mattress ModelsTEMPUR-Cloud
TEMPUR-Adapt
TEMPUR-ProAdapt
TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt
TEMPUR-breeze
Cocoon by Sealy Chill
Response
Conform
Hybrid
Posturepedic Plus
Mattress FeelsSoft, Medium, Medium Hybrid, FirmUltra Plush, Plush, Cushion Firm, Firm, Extra Firm, Ultra Firm
SizesTwin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King, Split Cal KingTwin, Twin Long, Full, Queen, King, Cal King
CertiPUR-US CertifiedYesYes
Hybrid VariantAvailableAvailable
Free ShippingWithin 48 contiguous USYes
Sleep Trial90 days100 days
Made InUSUS
Warranty10 YearsUp to 10 years

Mattress Types

Tempur-Pedic and Sealy offer a range of mattresses with different levels of support and firmness.

Here’s a look at the TEMPUR-Adapt and Sealy’s Hybrid line.

Between Tempur-Pedic and Sealy, you’ll find plenty of mattress choices. Each model is available in different feels and is designed to target specific sleep issues.

Tempur-Pedic’s flagship model is TEMPUR-Adapt, which follows the original memory foam formulation designed by NASA. An upgraded version, called TEMPUR-ProAdapt, features newer material and is the brand’s most-reviewed product. Meanwhile, TEMPUR-Cloud serves as the entry-level model while TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt bookends as the premium option.

Memory foam has always been criticized for retaining heat. With this in mind, Tempur also launched TEMPUR-breezeº, a foam mattress designed for a cooler sleep. The Breeze line currently comes in two variants — PRObreeze and LUXEbreeze — and is the most expensive in Tempur-Pedic’s catalogue.

Sealy’s most popular offering, on the other hand, is the Hybrid Line that combines innerspring support and a memory foam. There are also all-foam options like the specialty Cocoon Chill mattress, and the Conform Line. If memory foam is not your thing, you can opt for Sealy’s innerspring mattress line called Response. Recently, the brand also introduced the Posturepedic Plus. As its name suggests, this hybrid mattress offers more targeted support for a sleeper’s back and core.

With Tempur-Pedic, mattress feels come in soft, medium, and firm. In addition, the hybrid models for Adapt, ProAdapt, and Breeze lines offers what the brand calls a Medium Hybrid firmness. Sealy has more range in terms of firmness. Its mattresses come in plush, ultra plush, firm, cushion firm, extra firm, and ultra firm.

Material and Construction

Across their catalogue, Tempur-Pedic and Sealy boast different materials and construction.

A closer inspection reveals the many layers that make up these premium mattresses.

Tempur-Pedic is best known for using TEMPUR material for its memory foams. Aside from this main layer, denser foams also serve as either transitional layers or as a support base. However, there are variations between models.

Cooler beds like the Breeze line employ a phase-change material for its cover to improve airflow and breathability. This is on top of the dual cover system also found in the ProAdapt and LuxeAdapt lines. The “Adapt” models, on the other hand, largely differ in the amount of TEMPUR used. At 13-inches thick, the LuxeAdapt currently offers the most for better sleep elevation and body contouring.

Sealy’s approach varies a bit from Tempur-Pedic. Each of its mattress lines also come in three different collections. For example, if you want to get a Response mattress, you can choose between three variants: Essentials, Performance, or Premium. Essentials gives you a standard mattress with the basic features associated with the line. If you opt for Performance or Premium on the other hand, you get thicker mattresses with additional support.

Since these two collections are the top of the line, you also get more advanced features. This could be the use of AllergenProtect for the bed’s cover or a reinforced coiling system if you opt for an innerspring or hybrid mattress among others. Lastly, the top layer of Sealy’s mattresses are usually a combination of memory and gel foams. However, they vary in the use of cooling and comfort materials.

Support and Performance

Tempur-Pedic is more responsive although Sealy offers better back support.

Tempur-Pedic (left) and Seal (right) aim to deliver a well-support, good night’s sleep.

Except for Cocoon’s Chill mattress, every Sealy line includes the company’s proprietary Posturepedic technology. Designed with the help of orthopedic specialists, the feature is a special layer added to the mattresses where it slumps the fastest. The result is a zoned support system that specifically targets the back and core of a sleeper.

In terms of edge support, the Response and Hybrid lines fare the best as expected. The former is a full innerspring mattress that features either foil or a flexible coil border. Sealy’s Hybrid mattress, on the other hand, all use the coil border system. However, if you prefer a more responsive bed, then Sealy’s Conform might be the closest to what Tempur-Pedic also offers. As an all-foam mattress, Conform contours well with a sleeper’s body.

Still, Tempur-Pedic has the advantage when it comes to overall responsiveness. After all, this is the bread and butter of the brand. Both the Adapt and ProAdapt mattresses let sleepers really sink into the bed. The LuxeAdapt, on the other hand, offers a more luxurious, cradling feel. Since these are all-foam options, edge support isn’t the best. Bounce may also be lacking, too. If you’re someone who moves around while sleeping, you might like the performance of Tempur-Pedic’s hybrid mattresses better.

Comfort

For hot sleepers, Sealy’s Chill Mattress and Tempur-Pedic’s Breeze lines are great options.

Cooling, breathable covers feature prominently in these brands.

When it comes to temperature control, both brands carry specific mattress lines for hot sleepers. Sealy’s Cocoon Chill is a favorite, thanks to a cover that uses proprietary-phase change materials. It’s the same technology you’ll find in Tempur-Pedic’s breeze mattresses as well. Of course, if you prefer to stick to Sealy’s main catalogue, you’ll find the best comfort features are available in the Performance and Premium collections. Between the lines, however, we find Sealy’s Hybrid to be more versatile compared to Response.

Tempur-Pedic’s memory foam mattresses also face a similar issue. Unlike other types of beddings, the TEMPUR material tends to trap heat. To address this, the brand launched its Breeze line that claims to offer breathable materials. According to Tempur-Pedic, the Pro- and LuxeBreeze variants come with covers that can deliver up to 8º cooler sleep. Among the Adapt mattresses, on the other hand, you’ll find the Pro- and LuxeAdapt best for hot sleepers.

Verdict

Sealy mattresses are a less expensive alternative to Tempur-Pedic’s sky-high prices.

Even though Sealy was acquired by Tempur-Pedic, the brand still retains its identity as the go-to for innerspring mattresses. There is still something about a coiled bed that makes it feel sturdier and more durable than an all-foam one. And while Sealy does have a hybrid variant too, the Response line is the best example of what the brand offers: great support, a little more bounce, and a cooler sleep.

In contrast, Tempur-Pedic has built its reputation with its use of the TEMPUR material. But it hasn’t rested on its laurels. Its Pro- and LuxeAdapt lines, for instance, feature upgraded material and construction that aims to address issues with cooling. Of course, there are also dedicated mattresses like the Breeze line for hot sleepers. Regardless of their differences, they all retain the unmatched responsiveness Tempur-Pedic offers.

So where should you buy your mattress? Perhaps the deciding factor will be the price. Sealy is so much more affordable compared to Tempur-Pedic. Plus, most of its lines almost mirror that of its former rival’s. If you’re on a budget, then go for Sealy. It’s under the same company as Tempur-Pedic anyway, so you’ll enjoy similar customer support, warranty policy, and free shipping. But if you really want to treat yourself, then there’s no investment as good as Tempur-Pedic. Yes, the price tag maybe higher but your sleep will be so good you’d forget how much you spent on a mattress.

FAQs

📌 Does Tempur-Pedic offer free shipping?

Yes, Tempur-Pedic offer free shipping but only to the 48 contiguous US. Additional fees may apply for residents in Alaska and Hawaii.

📌 Are Tempur-Pedic and Sealy the same?

No, they’re not. Sealy was a rival bedding manufacturer before Tempur-Pedic acquired it.

📌 Does Tempur-Pedic offer hybrid mattresses?

All of Tempur-Pedic’s beds come in a hybrid option except for Cloud, LuxeAdapt, and LUXEbreeze.

📌 What is Sealy’s return policy?

If you’re not happy with your Sealy mattress, you can simply return it. The company will take care of pick up within the 100-day sleep trial.

Last update on 2020-09-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

RELATED  Brooklinen vs Frette (2020): Where Should You Buy Your Linens?
Mari Bassig
Mari Bassig

Senior Editor, writer and researcher passionate about gadgets, social media, and music.