Tempur-Pedic vs Posturepedic (2021): Which Mattress Is Better?

Choosing between a Tempur-Pedic or Posturepedic mattress is always an interesting experience. Although both brandish the “pedic” label and belong to the same company, there are still some key differences between them, particularly in terms of material and construction. But with so many types, sizes, and feels to choose from between their respective catalogs, which one do you get? Keep reading below for our comparison of the two mattress brands.

Tempur-Pedic vs Posturepedic Comparison Chart

Key Difference

Both Tempur-Pedic and Posturepedic offer an extensive catalog of mattresses.

Tempur-Pedic is best known for pioneering the use of Tempur material in mattresses. Today, its premium memory foam beds are some of the most sought-after in the market. Posturepedic, on the other hand, is actually a brand name under another brand called Sealy. Popular for its innerspring mattresses, Sealy was acquired by Tempur-Pedic back in 2012. Posturepedic itself is the name of proprietary support technology used in Sealy mattresses.

Models

Currently, Tempur-Pedic offers five different models. TEMPUR-Cloud is its entry-level product that comes in a 10-inch profile and which uses the original TEMPUR material. For hot sleepers, the brand’s breeze mattresses are available in two variants: PRObreeze and LUXEbreeze. Meanwhile, the Adapt, ProAdapt, and LuxeAdapt line of mattresses boast variations of Tempur material thickness in their support layer.

Sealy’s Posturepedic, on the other hand, is available in four lines: Response, Conform, Hybrid, and Posturepedic Plus. Each of the four lines also comes in three collections. For the Conform and Hybrid lines, you have Essentials, Performance, and Premium. Meanwhile, on the Response line, the Premium collection is called Posturepedic Plus. The different collections under Posturepedic Plus are unnamed but also vary in terms of features offered.

Mattress Construction

Unlike Tempur-Pedic, Posturepedic offers an innerspring option.

In terms of construction, Tempur-Pedic mattresses are available either as an all-foam model or a hybrid variant. At the core of the regular mattresses is the use of high-density polyfoam for its support layer. The hybrid mattresses, on the other hand, include 1,000 premium spring coils encased in the same polyfoam material for added support.

The brand’s LuxeAdapt and LUXEbreeze models are the thickest in terms of profile at 13-inches. In contrast, TEMPUR-Cloud comes in only at 11-inches. The use of cooling technology also varies across the catalog, with the breeze models adding phase change material to the dual-cover system standard to most Tempur-Pedic mattresses.

Meanwhile, you can get Posturepedic mattresses in three models: all-foam, hybrid, or innerspring. Its construction is largely based on having denser and more supportive materials around the core region of the bed where a sleeper’s lumbar area rests.

The all-foam models form Sealy’s Conform Line which uses a gel foam for its base and top layer. In contrast, the Hybrid Line makes use of an encased coil system combined with Sealy’s own brand of memory foam.

The Response Line, on the other hand, is a traditional, innerspring option but which still features layers of comfort and memory foams. Lastly, Posturepedic Plus employs targeted support, a coil system for the edges, plus a regular encased coil system similar to that use in Sealy’s Response mattresses.

Support and Performance

Tempur-Pedic is better at pressure relief and motion isolation while Posturepedic has the edge in terms of back and edge support.

If you’re a side sleeper looking for pressure relief, you’ll find Tempur-Pedic’s mattresses fare better than Posturepedic. The regular, all-foam options really let a sleeper sink into the bed, with the premium foams contouring and conforming nicely to the shoulders and hips. Because it’s slow-moving too, Tempur-Pedic offers great motion isolation. People who tend to toss and turn around while sleeping shouldn’t worry waking up their partner lying on a Tempur-Pedic.

But for more targeted support, Posturepedic is a nice alternative. The brand’s Premium collections incorporate the Posturepedic technology along the central region of the mattress, making it ideal for aiding sleeping posture. It’s a feature that the brand claims was developed with the help of orthopedic specialists. If you are experiencing backaches or find Tempur-Pedic mattresses too soft, then the Response and Hybrid Lines are worth looking into.

Responsiveness, however, will largely depend on the mattress model you get. Hybrid variants from both Tempur-Pedic and Posturepedic offer a bit more bounce than their foam-only products. As expected, the Response Line from Posturepedic excels in this area, giving users more of a “sleeping-on-top” experience. Sealy’s brand of mattresses also offers better edge support, which is something to consider if you like sitting on the edge of your bed.

Comfort

Posturepedic’s innerspring mattresses are cooler compared to Tempur-Pedic’s offerings.

Similar to support and responsiveness, comfort depends on the mattress model you get specific to your needs. For most regular sleepers, a memory foam option from either Tempur-Pedic and Posturepedic gives a hugging sensation that relaxes and soothes. A heavier person or someone suffering from back pain, however, will prefer a little more firmness.

Innerspring mattresses like Posturepedic’s Response line are also cooler to sleep on. Because of the coils used in the construction, there’s plenty of room for air to flow, translating to improved breathability. Tempur-Pedic’s Breeze line tries to emulate this by using Tempur material that comes with ventilation channels. If you’re a hot sleeper, you’ll probably find Sealy’s innerspring mattresses better. But if you want comfort and pressure relief, the best bet would be a hybrid model regardless of the brand.

Verdict

If you want an innerspring mattress, Posturepedic is the way to go. However, if you’re simply looking to invest in a better mattress, then go for Tempur-Pedic.

While Tempur-Pedic and Sealy’s Posturepedic are under the same umbrella company, there are still plenty of reasons to choose one over the other. Sealy’s line of mattresses, for instance, is far more affordable than Tempur-Pedic’s. However, it’s their bread-and-butter innerspring mattresses that set the brand apart. Combined with the Posturepedic technology, it’s the kind of bed made for people who want a firm, cool mattress that can remedy their back pains.

Tempur-Pedic, on the other hand, is the better choice for most consumers. Although Posturepedic is available in hybrid and all-foam variants as well, there’s a reason why Tempur-Pedic’s mattresses cost more. That extra cost is an investment in a tried-and-tested Tempur material that makes all the difference. If you have deep pockets and simply want to upgrade your sleeping experience, Tempur-Pedic should be a priority.

FAQs