We are reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Janome HD3000 vs Singer 4452 (2021): Which Heavy-Duty Sewing Machine Should You Buy?

Choosing the right sewing machine for your home projects can be hard. If you are a beginner and you don’t know what to look for, it can add to the confusion and you might get overwhelmed. Even experienced users sometimes find it hard to pick a model to buy because there are a lot of good quality sewing machines out there.

To help you with your search, let’s start by picking models from two of the best brands in heavy duty sewing machines, Janome and Singer. We’ll take a look at and compare the Janome HD3000 and the Singer 4452.

Janome HD3000 vs Singer 4452 Comparison Chart

Janome HD3000Singer 4452
 Janome HD3000 Heavy-Duty Sewing Machine with 18 Built-in Stitches + Hard CaseSINGER | Heavy Duty 4452 Sewing Machine with 110 Stitch Applications, Metal Frame, Built-In Needle...
PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
Needle ThreaderYesYes
Built-in Stitches1832
Max Sewing Speed8601100
Free ArmYesYes
Reverse StitchYesYes
Stitch Lengthup to 4mmup to 4mm
Stitch Widthup to 6.5mmup to 6mm
Adjustable Presser FootYesYes
Bobbin SystemTop drop-inTop drop-in
Dimensions16″ x 7.2″ x 11.3″15.5″ x 6.25″ x 12″
Weight18.7 lbs14.6 lbs

Design

Both the Janome HD3000 and the Singer 4452 have heavy duty metal frames, ideal for stitching thicker fabrics.

A side by side look at the Janome HD3000 (left) and the Singer 4452 (right).

The build quality for both the Janome HD3000 and the Singer 4452 are excellent. The HD3000 has an aluminum body while the 4452 has a heavy duty metal frame. Both of these sewing machines will last a long time, as long as you treat them with a little bit of care. Having said that, the Janome HD3000 does feel a bit more premium.

When it comes to their actual appearance, the HD3000 is slightly wider and weighs more, with a dimension of 16″ x 7.2″ x 11.3″ and weight of 18.7 lbs. The Singer 4452, on the other hand, is slightly taller and weighs less, with a dimension of 15.5″ x 6.25″ x 12″ and weight of 14.7 lbs. The 4452 is easier to carry around as it is lighter but the difference is not that big, the HD3000 is still a very portable machine.

Both of these machines come with a top drop-in bobbin system. It makes it easier to monitor your thread supply so you won’t run out in the middle of a sewing project. It’s also easier to use, you just simply drop the bobbin in and follow the directions on pulling the thread through the case. Perfect for beginners and even experienced ones as it is more convenient and can save a lot of time.

Performance and Features

The Singer 4452 has a more powerful motor, capable of up to 1,100 stitches per minute.

Needle plates for both the Janome HD3000 (left) and Singer 4452 (right).

These two sewing machines are very capable and will both do a fine job for all your home sewing projects. They both come with essential features such as reverse stitching, needle threaders, adjustable stitch width and length, free arm, adjustable presser foot, a top drop-in bobbin system and more. Both of these machines are capable of sewing through many different types of fabrics as well as handle thicker ones such as leather, denim and vinyl.

One of the differences between the two is the motor and the maximum stitch per minute. The Singer 4452 has a more powerful motor, capable of faster stitching – up to 1,100 stitches per minute. The Janome HD3000 can go up to a max of 860 stitches per minute.

Another difference is the number of built-in stitches, with the Singer 4452 having 32 types and the Janome HD3000 having 18. This might be useful for people that need those additional stitches for different projects so it is something to consider.

Overall, the Singer wins this category as it has more features.

Accessories

The Janome HD3000 comes with a hard cover but fewer accessories overall. The Singer 4452, on the other hand, has more bonus accessories but it only comes with a soft cover.

The Singer 4452 comes with a lot of accessories.

Included accessories for the Janome HD3000 are as follows: blind hem foot, automatic buttonhole foot, bobbin (specialized), rolled hem foot, zig-zag foot and overedge foot. It also comes with a hard cover.

The Singer 4452 comes with the following accessories: even feed/walking foot, clearance plate, non-stick foot, general purpose foot, buttonhole foot, button sewing foot, zipper foot, needles, bobbins, auxilliary spool pin, screwdriver, spool caps, spool pin felt and a seam ripper. It comes with a soft cover as well.

As you can see, the Singer 4452 comes with more accessories. While you can buy these accessories separately, and they are not expensive at all, getting them alongside the machine when you buy it is more convenient.

Verdict

The Singer 4452 offers more value for the money and you should buy it if you are looking for a heavy duty sewing machine for your home arts and crafts/upholstery projects.

The Singer 4452 is our recommended heavy duty sewing machine. It simply offers a lot more than the Janome HD3000. It has more built-in stitches and the more powerful motor can save you a lot of time, if you can take advantage of it.

The Janome HD3000, in contrast, does have fewer features but it is still a good performer. Furthermore, it’s build quality is superb and it does feel like the more premium product. It’s a good choice if you don’t need the extra stitches and the faster sewing speed of the Singer 4452.

FAQs

๐Ÿ“Œ Is Janome better than Singer?

It depends on your level of experience using sewing machines. Singer tends to be more suitable for beginners.

๐Ÿ“Œ What is the difference between Singer 4432 and 4452?

There’s not much difference between the two when it comes to features and power, in fact, they’re the same. The only difference is that the Singer 4452 comes with more accessories.

๐Ÿ“Œ Can the Janome HD3000 sew leather?

Yes, the Janome HD3000 is a heavy duty sewing machine capable of sewing thick fabrics such as leather.

๐Ÿ“Œ What is the difference between Janome HD1000 and HD3000?

These two machines are very different products. One of the differences is their bobbin system, the HD3000 comes with a top drop-in while the HD1000 has a front-loading system. To get a more comprehensive comparison between the two, take a look at our Janome HD3000 vs Janome HD1000 guide.

Last update on 2021-07-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

RELATED  Cricut Comparison Chart (2021): Comparing the Top-rated Cricut Machines
Carlo Salvador

Senior Editor at Compare Before Buying. Writer and researcher passionate about fitness, gaming and music.