Gelato and Printful are two leading POD platforms, each offering unique features. Gelato stands out for its global reach, impressive product customization and competitive pricing, while Printful is known for its extensive product catalog and diverse printing methods. However, after careful comparison, we find that Gelato holds the edge in several key areas, including shipping speed, scalability, and international support, to name a few. Below is our in-depth comparison of the two.
Navigation
Gelato vs Printful Comparison Chart
Gelato vs Printful Overview
Gelato offers efficient and cost-effective Print-on-Demand service
Gelato is a leading print-on-demand (POD) service with production in 32 countries through over 100 print partners. Known as the world’s largest on-demand production network, Gelato offers a wide range of products, including apparel, photo books, phone cases, wall art, and more. The platform integrates with popular eCommerce sites like Shopify and Etsy, among others, allowing users to customize products with Gelato’s design tools.
Printful is a print-on-demand platform that offers 300+ customizable products, including apparel, glassware, and posters. Printful handles all aspects of order fulfillment, from packing to shipping, with fulfillment centers in nine countries. Similar to Gelato, Printful also integrates with sites like Etsy, Shopify and more.
Gelato Features
- Over 200 products
- Personalization Studio
- Price Navigator
- Over 140 production partners
- 32 production countries
- 60+ logistics partners
- Free shipping on orders over $300
- 4.8 stars on Shopify app store
Printful Features
- Over 300 products
- Merch Share
- 11 fulfillment centers in 9 countries
- Free shipping on orders over $500
- 4.6 stars on Shopify app store
Product Range, Pricing and Profit
Printful offers a broader product range, but Gelato offers better pricing and profit potential
In terms of product range, Printful holds a slight edge over Gelato, offering a broader selection across various categories. Printful’s best-sellers include unisex t-shirts, hats, matte posters, blankets, and drinkware, among others. Gelato still offers over 200 products, including shirts, posters, wall art, phone cases, bags, and personalized apparel.
However, when it comes to pricing and profit potential, Gelato takes the lead. Gelato’s offerings are generally more cost-effective, with fixed prices for each product, making it easier to predict costs and profit margins. In contrast, Printful charges a base price plus additional fees for printing and branding, which can affect overall profitability.
Print Quality & Shipping
Both Gelato and Printful offer excellent quality prints, but Gelato offers faster shipping
Both Gelato and Printful excel in print quality, making them top choices for print-on-demand services. Gelato adheres to international standards and promotes sustainable production, carefully selecting print partners based on quality, professionalism, and production excellence rather than price. Gelato provides detailed information about each product’s quality, including fabric softness, thickness, and key features, ensuring customers are well-informed before purchasing.
Printful, on the other hand, employs a three-step quality check process for every order. Automated software first assesses the design’s graphic quality, followed by a fulfillment specialist’s inspection during production, and a final quality check after customization. Both platforms guarantee high-quality prints, making them reliable choices for any business.
However, Gelato outperforms Printful in shipping speed, thanks to its extensive network of fulfillment centers and printing partners. This allows Gelato to fulfill orders more quickly, making it a particularly strong choice for businesses targeting markets outside the US, where its large network ensures faster delivery.
Integrations & Tools
Gelato and Printful offer seamless integration with the most popular online stores, however, Gelato offers better customization tools for users
Both Gelato and Printful seamlessly integrate with popular eCommerce platforms like Etsy, Amazon, Shopify, WooCommerce, and Wix. However, Printful has a slight edge in connectivity, as it also supports stores that Gelato currently doesn’t, such as eBay and Adobe eCommerce. Additionally, both platforms offer API integration for connecting to online stores.
When it comes to creator tools, both platforms provide the essentials like mockup generation, design editors, analytics, and mobile apps. However, each platform also offers unique tools. Gelato stands out with its pricing tools and the exceptional Personalization Studio, which you can read more about here, but to give you an idea of how it works, here’s an excerpt from our review.
Personalization Studio is a sophisticated tool designed to simplify the creation and delivery of custom products. By integrating seamlessly with major platforms like Etsy and Shopify, it enables businesses to offer tailored experiences to their customers, enhancing both personalization and order fulfillment efficiency. This tool covers the entire process from design to delivery, allowing users to craft unique designs while enabling customers to make specific requests directly through online stores. Gelato is the only Print-on-Demand platform that offers a tool for business owners to sell customizable products in an automated way, and this separates them from the competition.
On the other hand, Printful offers a unique merch-share service, allowing companies and teams to create and purchase custom items with shared graphics and assets, simplifying group orders.
Plans
Gelato’s flexible pricing plans offer more features and cost-saving opportunities compared to Printful’s
Gelato offers flexible and competitive pricing plans that cater to various business needs. Its free tier provides essential features, including production across 32 countries, integration with platforms like Shopify and Etsy, and access to a design editor with free product mockups. For $24 per month, the Gelato+ plan adds 10% off products, premium mockups, and advanced personalization tools. The Gelato Gold plan, at $119 per month, includes up to 30% off branded labels and packaging inserts, as well as advanced pricing tools with Price Navigator. The custom-priced Gelato Platinum plan offers bespoke discounts, exclusive community events, a dedicated customer success manager, and tailored implementation services.
While Printful does not charge a subscription fee, it offers membership options for additional benefits. Printful Growth, available to vendors with $12k in profits or for $24.99 per month, includes discounts and personalized services. Printful Business, for vendors with over $60k in profits, provides further discounts and additional perks. Despite Printful’s benefits, Gelato’s tiered plans offer more extensive features and cost-saving opportunities.
Verdict
Gelato excels with global reach, product customization, cost-effective pricing, and fast shipping
In summary, Gelato stands out as a superior print-on-demand service compared to Printful due to its extensive global network, which facilitates faster shipping and more cost-effective solutions. With production in 32 countries and a robust range of over 200 products, Gelato offers significant advantages in pricing predictability and profit potential. Its Personalization Studio and competitive pricing plans, including free shipping on orders over $300, enhance its appeal for businesses seeking efficient, high-quality, and customizable products.
While Printful has a larger product range and some unique features, Gelato’s comprehensive service and flexible plans make it a top choice for print-on-demand needs.