We are reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Brooklinen vs Buffy (2022): The Better Bedroom Pick

After choosing and buying a new mattress, you’ll need high quality bedding to complete your dream sleep set-up. Luckily, there are a lot of stores to choose from online when looking for luxury sheets, comforters, and pillows, among other things. Two of the biggest and most successful bedding startups right now, Brooklinen and Buffy, are easily accessible online. If you’re trying to decide which company you’ll let help decorate your perfect bedroom, continue reading below for a comparison of the two brands and some of their popular offerings.

Deal Finder
Brooklinen Luxe 7 Piece Sheet Set

Brooklinen's best-selling Luxe Sheets are 100% long-staple cotton with a super-smooth 480-thread count thanks to its luminous sateen weave. OEKO-TEX certified.

Check Price on Amazon
We are reader supported. When you buy through our links we may earn an affiliate commission.

Brooklinen vs Buffy Comparison Chart

BrandBrooklinenBuffy
Best-selling Product
PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
Bedding ProductsSheets, comforters, pillows, blankets, baby beddingSheets, comforters, pillows, duvets
Bed SizesTwin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cali KingTwin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cali King
Free Trial?NoYes
Oeko-Tex certified?YesYes
Return Policy365 days for majority of products30 days

Sheets and Duvet Covers

Brooklinen offers a wide variety, while Buffy opts to focus on planet-friendliness. 

Brooklinen’s percale Classic Hardcore Sheet Bundle (left) and Buffy’s Eucalyptus Sheet Set (right).

Buffy’s specialty sheets and duvet covers are made from 100% eucalyptus grown and harvested in Czechia and Austria. They explain their fabric of choice as an environmentally-conscious choice: eucalyptus is as soft as cotton, gets softer with each wash, and uses less water than cotton sheets during production. The dyes they use are also Earth-friendly, using natural colors from pomegranates, turmeric, and other plants and minerals.

Green thinking is a consistent design feature of Buffy’s products, since its founder Leo Wang made it a priority and part of his company’s mission. However, this commitment comes with a trade-off: your choices for Buffy sheets and duvet covers are limited to just their eucalyptus set. If you decide that the sheet weave isn’t your cup of tea, the duvet cover doesn’t go well with your comforter, or if you want a higher or lower thread count for your sheets, you’ll have to look elsewhere.

Brooklinen spoils its customers for choice by comparison. You can choose from their sateen, percale, linen, and heathered cashmere sheets. The differences lie in the weave and material used: their percale and sateen sheets use 100% long staple cotton, their linen is made from 100% Belgian and French flax, while their heathered cashmere is a mixture of 5% Himalayan cashmere and 95% cotton.

These give you a wide assortment to choose from depending on what kind of feel you want for your bed. If you prefer a hotel-quality, crisp texture to your sheets that looks photogenic even when creased, Brooklinen’s Classic Sheet percale bundles is your best bet. If breathability is the most important part of your sheets’ quality, go with their Linen Sheet bundles. Heathered Cashmere and the sateen Luxe Sheet bundles are best for sleepers who love the feel of soft, silky sheets. Brooklinen offers duvet covers categorized in the same way.

Comparing specifics, Buffy’s sheets come in at a single-ply 300 thread count while Brooklinen’s cotton sheets are available in 270 (percale) and 480 (sateen) thread counts. Brooklinen’s sheets are slightly more affordable than Buffy’s: their full Luxe Hardcore Sheet Bundle (which includes both a fitted and a flat sheet, 4 pillowcases, and a duvet cover) starts at $228 at the time of writing, while Buffy sells their Eucalyptus Sheets and Eucalyptus Duvet Cover come separately at $169 and $99 respectively (for a twin-sized bed).

Comforters

Buffy continues with eco-friendly eucalyptus, while Brooklinen has more options (including a weighted comforter).

Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter (left) and Buffy Breeze (right).

Brooklinen once again has a more expansive array of comforter choices. Customers can pick from products filled with natural down, down alternatives, and even a weighted comforter. Both their natural down and down alternative duvets are available in All-Season and Lightweight options. All-Season comforters are a tad heavier due to more fill, which makes it ideal for rainy days, cold winters, and places where it doesn’t get too hot in general. The down that they use for their comforters is ethically sourced from farms in Canada and filled into a 100% cotton sateen shell, which is then treated with antimicrobial agents to ensure the sleeper’s safety from any germs.

If you’re allergic to down or if you prefer non-animal products, Brooklinen’s down alternatives feel just like their natural down offerings but are made of 100% hypoallergenic polyfill. For those who want the feeling that a weighted duvet provides, their version is filled with a mixture of the same polyfill down alternative and evenly distributed glass microbeads.

Buffy has two comforters for sale: the Buffy Cloud and the Buffy Breeze. Both the Cloud and the Breeze have 100% eucalyptus fiber shells. The Cloud provides a fluffy feel with its triangle stitch pattern and fill made of 100% recycled BPA-free PET. According to Buffy’s website Each Cloud comforter recycles approximately 50 plastic bottles. Meanwhile, the Breeze has a temperature-regulating eucalyptus fiber fill that works better for sleepers in warmer climates.

Pillows

Brooklinen and Buffy both put an emphasis on balancing comfort and support.

Brooklinen standard plush down pillow (left) and Buffy Cloud pillow (right).

Brooklinen and Buffy have pillows that are similar to the choices they offer for comforters. Both brands have three options for firmness (firm, medium, and soft) and are available in either standard or king size. Brooklinen’s pillows are made from the same material as their duvets. Their 100% cotton sateen shells filled with either humanely-sourced natural down or polyfill.

On the other hand, Buffy sells its customers pillows made with 100% eucalyptus fiber filled with recycled PET. With their pillows, Buffy completes their green bedding set that would make Mother Nature proud. Price-wise, Buffy’s pillows are slightly more affordable. Their standard-size pillows are $49 each, compared to Brooklinen’s pillows that start at $59. That sixty-buck price tag can go up to $89, depending on the material and size that you choose.

Verdict

Options abound for Brooklinen, while Buffy works well for green consumers.

Deal Finder
Brooklinen Luxe 7 Piece Sheet Set

Brooklinen's best-selling Luxe Sheets are 100% long-staple cotton with a super-smooth 480-thread count thanks to its luminous sateen weave. OEKO-TEX certified.

Check Price on Amazon
We are reader supported. When you buy through our links we may earn an affiliate commission.

If you’re striving to be more environmentally-conscious and do your part to help reduce waste, buy from Buffy. Their attention to detail when it comes to producing green products pervades all parts of their business. They keep an eye on water consumption during production and their CO2 transmissions during transport.

Buffy’s materials are specifically chosen for their planet-friendliness without compromising on comfort. However, they don’t offer their sheets and duvet cover in a set like Brooklinen does. This means that your total purchase can add up to a pretty hefty amount, depending on what you’re buying.

For those looking for a lot of comforters, sheets, and pillows to mix and match, Brooklinen is your best choice. They have a considerable collection of choices, allowing their customers to fine-tune their purchases to fit the sleeping experience that they’re looking for. They also have more color options than other brands. With Brooklinen, you can ensure that your bedroom remains color-coordinated.

If you’re just buying an extra pillow or comforter, the prices that Brooklinen has does come a tiny bit steeper than that of other competitors. However, Brooklinen still offers more bang for your buck if you’re looking to start from scratch for your bedroom. The bundles that they offer already come with fitted and flat sheets, along with up to 4 pillowcases and a duvet cover depending on your budget.

RELATED  Leesa Original vs Hybrid (2022): What's the Difference?
Mauie Flores

Senior Editor at Compare Before Buying, blogger and content creator passionate about writing, music, and good food.