We are reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Brooklinen Luxe vs Classic (2020): Which Bed Sheet Will Give You The Best Sleep?

If you think it’s about time you upgraded your ratty old sheets to a more high-quality set, you can’t go wrong with the Brooklinen Luxe or the Brooklinen Classic. That said, they have some pretty big differences and so it’s crucial that you pick the one that will best suit your sleeping preferences. The Brooklinen Classic, for example, is more for those who want sheets that are barely there while the Brooklinen Luxe is perfect for those who like sheets that have more weight to them. To help you decide which one is the better match for you, here’s an in-depth comparison of the Brooklinen Classic and the Brooklinen Luxe. 

Brooklinen Luxe vs Classic Comparison Chart​

ModelBrooklinen LuxeBrooklinen Classic
 
PriceCheck Price on AmazonCheck Price at Brooklinen
Fabric100% long-staple cotton100% long-staple cotton
Thread Count480270
WeaveSateenPercale
CharacteristicsSoft, heavy, luxurious

Light, crisp, breathable

Lifetime WarrantyYesYes

Fabric

Both the Brooklinen Classic and the Brooklinen Luxe are made of 100% cotton.


Brooklinen makes sure to use long-staple cotton for a stronger weave.

Both the Brooklinen Classic and the Brooklinen Luxe are made of 100% cotton and not just the usual short fiber type. Brooklinen makes sure to use long-staple cotton that has long and silky fibers, allowing for a much stronger weave. This way, you don’t have to worry about your bed sheet pilling or fraying after just a couple of washes.

So why is cotton the perfect material for bed sheets? For one, it’s very breathable and is able to wick away moisture. This is great news for those who tend to heat up quite a bit while they’re sleeping. You don’t have to lay in your own sweat anymore and can instead enjoy the rest of your night all dry and cool. Also, cotton is very low maintenance as all you have to do is wash and dry it. Just be sure to follow the manufacturer’s instructions. 

RELATED  Brooklinen vs Buffy (2020): The Better Bedroom Pick

Thread Count

The Brooklinen Luxe has a higher thread count than the Brooklinen Classic.

 

The Luxe line has a 480 thread count while the Classic line only has 270.

It’s hard to use thread count as a sign of quality because some companies like to cheat. By counting the ply within the thread, they’re able to make it seem like their bed sheets have a higher thread count. Fortunately, Brooklinen only uses single-ply yarn and so there’s no way for them to pad their numbers. That said, you can take their thread counts as a true sign of how tight their weave is. 

If we were to compare the thread counts of the Brooklinen Classic and the Brooklinen Luxe, the latter is the definite winner. It has a 480 thread count while the former is only at 270. The Luxe line has more than 100 threads woven together per square inch and so you can expect it to have a softer and denser feel. This makes it ideal for the winter as it’s sure to keep you warm and cozy. While the Classic line has a lower thread count, that doesn’t mean that you should dismiss it completely. As mentioned, Brooklinen uses single-ply yarn and so you can still count on the 270 thread count to be strong yet soft. The Classic line is also the better option during the summer because it’s light, cool, and crisp. 

Weave

The Classic line uses a percale weave while the Luxe line uses a sateen weave.

The percale weave is light and crisp while the sateen weave is soft and luxurious.

Aside from fabric and thread count, another important consideration when you’re choosing bed sheets is the weave. The Brooklinen Classic has percale weave while the Brooklinen Luxe has a sateen weave. So which one’s better? It all really depends on your preference. 

RELATED  Brooklinen vs Frette (2020): Where Should You Buy Your Linens?

With the percale weave, the cotton is combined and woven tightly and so it’s of better quality than the basic weave. It’s also strong and durable and has a lightness and crispness to it. That said, the Classic line is the better choice if you want bed sheets that are breathable and will last you a long time. As for the sateen weave, it’s quite different from the typical basic weave as it uses a one under and three over pattern. This way, more yarn is exposed, giving the Luxe line a softer feel and a shinier finish. So if you’re looking for bed sheets that will give you that soft and luxurious feel, you’re much better off with the Luxe line. 

Pricing

The Brooklinen Classic is more affordable than the Brooklinen Luxe. 

 

Both the Classic and Luxe lines come with a lifetime warranty.

You can probably already tell by their names that the Brooklinen Luxe is pricier than the Brooklinen Classic. It is, after all, the more luxurious option of the two. With the Luxe line, you’re going to be spending around $20 more than if you were to purchase from the Classic Line. To compare, the Luxe Core Sheet set in Queen is in the $190 range while the Classic Core Sheet set in Queen is in the $170 range. Whichever you end up choosing, however, Brooklinen will back your purchase up with a lifetime warranty. They’re very confident that their bed sheets will never pill or tear but in the unlikely event that they do, you can always send them back and they’ll repair or replace them for you for free. 

RELATED  Brooklinen vs Parachute (2020): Which Sheets Should You Buy?

Verdict

Go for the Luxe line if you’re looking for luxury but pick the Classic line if you want breathability.

Both the Brooklinen Classic and the Brooklinen Luxe are top quality choices and there really is no right or wrong answer. It all depends on your preference and what would make you more comfortable. The Classic line has a lower thread count and is made with the percale weave, making it light, crisp, and breathable. It’s the perfect choice for those who tend to sweat at night and would like to feel a lot cooler. It’s also the more budget-friendly option of the two, allowing you to save at least $20. As for the Luxe line, it has a much higher thread count and is made with the sateen weave and so it’s soft, dense, and luxurious. It’s definitely the right pick if you’re comforted by having some weight on top of you. You do, however, have to shell out a bit more if you’re buying from this line. 

FAQs

📌 What are the Brooklinen Classic and Luxe lines made out of?

Both the Classic and Luxe lines are made out of 100% long-staple cotton. 

📌 Which one has the higher thread count, the Classic or Luxe line?

The Luxe line has a higher thread count of 480. The Classic line only has a 270 thread count. 

📌 What type of weave do the Classic and Luxe lines have?

The Classic line has a percale weave while the Luxe line has a sateen weave.

📌 Which is more affordable, the Classic or Luxe line?

The Classic line is more affordable than the Luxe line by at least $20. 

Last update on 2020-08-08 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Denise Jose
Denise Jose

Senior Editor at Compare Before Buying. Researcher and yoga teacher passionate about article writing, photography, wellness, and mindfulness.