We are reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Best Coffee Percolator (2022): Which One Should You Buy?

While there are countless machines available for making coffee, there are still quite a few that prefer a coffee percolator. With a coffee percolator, not only will you be able to brew an intense coffee flavor, you’ll also be able to enjoy its wonderful aroma through the air while you wait. For a lot of people, this experience makes getting a coffee percolator worth it. That said, here are our top picks for the best coffee percolator in different categories, which includes the Farberware Classic Yosemite, the Presto Coffee Maker, the COLETTI Bozeman and the Primula Today.

Best Coffee Percolator Comparison Chart

ModelFarberware Classic Yosemite Presto Coffee Maker COLETTI BozemanPrimula Today
 Amazon productAmazon productAmazon productAmazon product
PriceAmazon productAmazon productAmazon productAmazon product
CategoryBest OverallElectric PercolatorOutdoorBest Budget
MaterialStainless SteelStainless SteelStainless SteelAluminum
Dishwasher SafeYesNoYesYes, but not recommended
WarrantyLifetime1 yearNot specifiedNot specified

Farberware Classic Yosemite

Best overall coffee percolator.

There’s an 8-cup and 12-cup version of the Farberware Classic Yosemite coffee percolator.

We picked the Farberware Classic Yosemite coffee percolator as the best overall since it offers the best combination of affordability, portability and simplicity. All you’ll need to get this to make great tasting coffee is a stovetop. Naturally, it is also a great coffee percolator for camping since you can use any heat source with it.

It is made with heavy duty stainless steel with a mirror finish. Looks-wise, this will fit in any kitchen, no matter what aesthetic you’re aiming for. Since it has a stainless steel construction and it has dishwasher safe parts, clean up is very easy as well.

It is available in either 8-cup or 12-cup capacity, so people with small or large families have a choice. With this percolator, you don’t need to use coffee filters as it comes with a permanent filter. This means that you don’t have to deal with messy coffee filters. The knob at the top is made from clear glass, which looks nice, but also functions as the indicator of your brewing process.

Presto Coffee Maker

If you’re looking to get an electric percolator, the Presto Coffee Maker is your best option.

With an electric coffee percolator like the Presto, chances of overcooking your coffee is basically zero.

If you want a more automated process, the Presto Coffee Maker is a great option as it is an electric coffee percolator. One of the drawbacks with stovetop coffee percolators is that you’ll need to monitor it as it brews coffee since there is a chance that your coffee might get burnt. With an electric percolator, this is practically a non-issue.

The Presto Coffee Maker comes with an indicator light that lets you know when the brewing is done. Also, it will switch to a keep warm mode to prevent your coffee from getting burnt. This is ideal if you don’t have the time to monitor your coffee as it brews, but you love the flavor and aroma that percolators produce.

It is made with stainless steel and it is a 12-cup capacity percolator. Unfortunately, when it comes to cleaning, you’ll need to do so manually, since it is not advised that you put this in the dishwasher. That said, it is very easy to clean as inside, it has a smooth finish.


Our top coffee percolator pick for camping/outdoors.

The COLETTI Bozeman comes in either 9 or 12 cup capacities.

Similar to the Farberware Classic, the COLETTI Bozeman is a stovetop coffee percolator that can be used with any heat source, such as your stove or a campfire. What makes it ideal for camping are its handle, which is made with heat-resistant rosewood and its flip top lid, which lessens the removable parts that can be prone to getting misplaced or damaged.

The COLETTI Bozeman has a stainless steel construction that can really take a beating, thus, making it ideal for outdoor and camping trips. While it is great for the outdoors, it will also work indoors. It is a nice looking coffee percolator that will fit in with any kitchen aesthetic. Since it is made with stainless steel, it is very easy to clean, either by hand or by using the dishwasher.

Primula Today Percolator

For people on a budget, the Primula Today is a wise choice.

The Primula Today is an aluminum percolator which makes it lightweight.

If you just want an affordable coffee percolator that you don’t have to worry about damaging or for outdoor use, the Primula Today is one of the best choices. It is very affordable since it comes with an aluminum construction, a plastic knob and a plastic handle. However, that doesn’t mean that it is fragile and will break easily. In fact, it has a solid build which is surprising considering that it is very cheap.

The Primula Today, just like with most coffee percolators, is easy to use and clean. However, since it is made with aluminum, it is recommended that you only wash it manually. Of course, you can put it in the dishwasher, but this will cause some issues, such as discoloration. Also, it won’t work on induction stovetops, but if you have a gas or electric stove, you’ll be able to use it without problem.


Coffee percolators are cheap and simple to use.

Amazon product

If you’re looking to get the best coffee percolator for the money, the Farberware Classic Yosemite is our recommendation. It is very affordable, has a sturdy build and it looks very nice. Also, you have an option to get either the 8-cup or 12-cup version, depending on how many people are in your household. As for electric percolators, the Presto Coffee Maker offers excellent performance while still being affordable.

If you like camping or any outdoor activities, the COLETTI Bozeman should be on your shortlist of coffee percolators. It is designed specifically for outdoor use but it will also work great in your kitchen. As for those on a strict budget, the Primula Today coffee percolator won’t disappoint.


๐Ÿ“Œ Do percolators make better coffee?

It depends on how you like your coffee. If you like stronger coffee, then a percolator will be better for you.

๐Ÿ“Œ Can I use a filter in a coffee percolator?

Yes, you can use a coffee filter in percolators even though they already have permanent filters.

๐Ÿ“Œ Should I get a stovetop or electric percolator?

It depends on your needs. If it is strictly for home use, then an electric percolator might be better since it is more convenient and easy to use. However, if you also want something that is portable, or if you often have power outages in your area, then a stovetop percolator is better.

๐Ÿ“Œ Can you put a percolator in the dishwasher?

It will depend on the specific model that you have. It’s best to consult your manual or the manufacturer’s site for instructions.

RELATED  Weber Go-Anywhere vs Smokey Joe (2021): Choosing Portable Grills
Carlo Salvador

Senior Editor at Compare Before Buying. Writer and researcher passionate about fitness, gaming and music.