We are reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Best Bed in a Box Mattress (2021): Which One Suits Your Needs?

Come to think of it, you spend at least one third of your day in bed. If this is the case, shouldn’t you also give some serious thought on picking the right mattress for you? You don’t even have to worry about going to the store because you can buy a boxed mattress online. But with a lot of brands offering bed in a box mattresses, it can be quite confusing. So in this article we have rounded up five popular brands to see which of them is the best bed in a box mattress. Read on and pick which one suits your needs.

Best Bed in a Box Mattress Comparison Chart

ModelImageReason To BuyPrice
Casper Original Foam MattressCasper Sleep Original Foam Mattress, QueenOne of the pioneers in the industry and known for its “zone support.”Check Price at Amazon
Tuft & Needle Original MattressTUFT & NEEDLE - Original Queen Adaptive Foam Mattress, CertiPUR-US, 100-Night TrialFoam has good motion isolation that’s perfect for those with sleeping partners.Check Price at Amazon
Nectar MattressNectar Full Mattress 12 Inch - Medium Firm Gel Memory Foam Mattress - 365 Night Trial - 5 Layers of...Five layers of comfort and has the longest warranty.Check Price at Amazon
Linenspa Memory Hybrid MattressLinenspa 12 Inch Memory Hybrid Plush-Individually Encased Coils-Edge Support-Quilted Foam Cover...Bestselling mattress on Amazon and is very affordable.Check Price at Amazon
Helix PlusSufficient support for sleepers on the heavy side.Check Price at Helix

Overall Best Bed in a Box 2021 – Casper Original

The term “bed-in-a-box” has already been synonymous with Casper.

Best Bed in a Box Mattress 2021
Casper Original Mattress has a comfort foam part called “AirScape.”

Casper is one of the more popular brands in the boxed mattress market. The Original mattress is one of their models and we consider it as the overall best bed in a box mattress in this group. Its polyester cover has the right thickness and softness. The perforated top layer is also Casper’s own AirScape foam that’s designed for a cooler and more comfortable sleep. The middle layer, on the other hand, is called Zoned Support and has three ergonomic zones that provide varied support for the upper, middle, and lower parts of the body. Finally, the polyurethane foam base completes the mattress and serves as its foundation.

Versatility and affordability are two things that we love about the Casper Original mattress. Its Zoned Support and AirScape foam layers make it suitable for all kinds of sleepers. Plus, you can always return the mattress in case you’re not happy within the 100-day trial period. It’s definitely a win-win for this one.

Pros

  • Affordable price
  • Zoned support
  • Hassle-free buying
  • 100-night trial period
  • 10-year warranty

Cons

  • Unboxing may be a struggle if you’re alone

Best Bed in a Box for Couples – Tuft & Needle Original Mattress

This medium-firm mattress has good motion isolation.

Best Bed in a Box Mattress For Couples
Couples will love Tuft and Needle’s 2-layer memory foam mattress that doesn’t give a sinking feeling.

Tuft and Needle is another affordable mattress option with a 100-night trial period and 10-year limited warranty. The mattress is 10 inches thick with a base layer made of open-cell polyurethane foam and an adaptive foam that has the properties of both latex and memory foam. Infused with graphite and ceramic gel beads, this comfort layer gives just the right firmness without the heat retention of which latex is known for.

We recommend Tuft and Needle’s Original mattress for couples or co-sleepers as it has the best motion isolation feature compared to the other mattresses we are featuring in this review. Sensitive sleepers will not need to worry about being woken up with their partner’s every move through the night.

Pros

  • Medium-firm rating
  • Good motion isolation
  • 100-night trial period
  • 10-year limited warranty
  • Free shipping and returns

Cons

  • Less edge support

Best Bed in a Box Under 1000 – Nectar Mattress

A five-layer mattress that’s still within budget range.

Best Bed in a Box Mattress Under 1000
Nectar’s Tencel cooling cover is one of its best assets.

One of the best bed in a box mattresses below $1000 is Nectar’s memory foam mattress. The mattress has five layers (covers included) and have different thicknesses. The top foam is a quilted gel memory foam with a Tencel cooling cover that is one of its best strengths. It’s as absorbent as cotton and adds an additional layer of comfort when sleeping.

Like the Casper Original mattress, its mattress contours around the body which is perfect for side or back sleepers. For stomach sleepers, however, there may be a bit of sinking that may cause shoulder and hip aches over time. Still, Nectar is worth the try especially since it offers a 365-night sleep trial.

Pros

  • Medium firmness
  • Tencel cooling cover
  • Good motion isolation
  • Lifetime warranty
  • 365-night sleep trial

Cons

  • Less edge support
  • May be too firm for lightweight persons
  • The body-hugging effect may be uncomfortable for some

Best Bed in a Box Under 500 – Linenspa

Soft memory foam hybrid that is very affordable.

Best Bed in a Box Mattress Under 500
Linenspa mattresses have three firmness options.

Since its launch in 2003, Linenspa has focused on producing mattresses and other sleep products at a budget-friendly price. This is one of the many reasons why Linenspa mattresses are popular online especially on Amazon. There are six models of Linenspa mattresses, but the 8-inch Memory Foam Hybrid mattress is often referred to as the Linenspa Mattress.

Linenspa mattresses are covered with a memory foam quilted into a blend of rayon, polyester, and propylene. The comfort layer is 1.5 inches of polyfoam making it cooler than other mattresses. Finally, the mattress is reinforced with 6.5 inches of innerspring coils. This not only gives the mattress a good support core but also allows more air to flow in between the coils.

Pros

  • Has good edge support because of innerspring coils
  • Multiple firmness and thickness settings
  • Lightweight and easy to set up
  • 10-year limited warranty

Cons

  • 30-night sleep trial only
  • Offers less pressure relief
  • Less motion isolation

Best Bed in a Box For Heavy Person – Helix Plus

Formerly branded as Helix Nightfall, Helix Plus has the longest warranty coverage in this round-up.

Best Bed in a Box Mattress For Heavy Person
Helix Plus is designed for plus-sized and tall sleepers.

Helix Plus is definitely the mattress for heavy persons as its designed with innerspring coils to provide their much needed support. Combined with its ultra-breathable Tencel cooling cover, bigger sleepers will never worry about heat retention and will surely stay cool and comfy all night long.

While the Helix Plus is marketed for the plus-sized sleepers, we also believe that smaller and average-sized back and side sleepers may like its high to medium level of firmness. It’s a luxury mattress that is still very affordable considering its extra features. Plus the 15-year warranty basically says this mattress is durable and long-lasting.

Pros

  • Tencel cooling cover
  • High medium level of firmness
  • Great edge support
  • Comfortable for back and side sleepers
  • 100-night sleep trial
  • 15-year limited warranty

Cons

  • Motion isolation is not as good as with an all-foam mattress

Verdict

The best bed in a box mattress is the one that will suit your budget and sleeping preferences.

All of the mattresses we featured in this round-up have their own strengths and weaknesses. Each one has special features that cater to a specific group of sleepers. Still we believe that the Casper Original Mattress is the overall best bed in a box in this group. While it doesn’t have perfect edge support because it’s an all-foam mattress, Casper’s Zoned Support and AirScape layers make it very versatile and dependable. It’s worth it’s price as well. Meanwhile, second best for us is Nectar because of its Tencel cooling cover and 365-night trial period.

FAQs

๐Ÿ“Œ Are Casper mattresses toxic?

Casper memory foam mattresses are CertiPUR certified. This ensures that it’s free from toxic materials such as formaldehyde, lead, mercury, ozone depleting substances, and VOCs.

๐Ÿ“Œ Are Tuft and Needle mattresses any good?

Tuft and Needle mattresses are one of the high quality affordable bed-in-a-box mattresses in the market today. In fact, it has high customer reviews on Amazon.

๐Ÿ“Œ Is it possible to flip a Nectar mattress to prevent sagging?

Nectar mattresses are design in a specific way so you cannot flip it to prevent sagging. You can rotate it instead.

๐Ÿ“Œ Why do bed in a box mattresses smell?

Bed in a box mattresses are stored in a box and emit an odor once unboxed. Rest assured that this will fade eventually after setting up your mattress.

Last update on 2021-07-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

RELATED  Solo Stove vs Tiki Fire Pit (2021): Comparing Award-Winning Fire Pits
Mauie Flores

Senior Editor at Compare Before Buying, blogger and content creator passionate about writing, music, and good food.