We are reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Avocado vs Brooklyn Bedding (2023): Comparing Flagship Mattresses

If you’re in the market for a hybrid mattress, Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding are two brands worth a look. While relatively a newcomer, Avocado has solidified its brand and expanded its catalog. It’s also known for its focus on eco-friendliness and use of natural materials.

Meanwhile, Brooklyn Bedding has been around since 1995. With years of experience, the company has gained a reputation for offering mattresses at competitive prices. Although they also offer beddings and accessories, the brand is well-known for customizable mattresses.

Avocado’s top-rated product is the Avocado Green Mattress, a hybrid bed that encapsulates the sustainable craftsmanship involved in the brand’s products. On the other hand, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress best embodies the tailored comfort Brooklyn Bedding offers. Below, we compare the two products to see which one you should buy.

Avocado vs Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Comparison Chart

ModelAvocado Green MattressBrooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress
 
Price
Key FeatureSafe and healthy top-rated certified organic mattressHigh-quality hybrid mattress with customizable comfort
Mattress TypeHybridHybrid
VariantsStandard, Pillow-topn/a
FirmnessStandard (medium-firm 7), Pillow-top (gentle-firm 6)Soft (3), Medium (5), Firm (7)
SizesTwin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California KingTwin, Twin XL, Split CA King, Full, Short Full, Queen, Short Queen, King, Short King, Olympic Queen, California King, RV King
Innerspring CoilsYesYes
Trial Period1-Year120 nights
Warranty25 years10 years
Free ShippingYesYes
Financing OptionsYesYes

Company Overview and Catalogue

Avocado is a newer bedding and mattress company that prides itself in eco-friendly products. In contrast, Brooklyn Bedding has years of experience and is known for customizable mattresses.

Avocado vs Brooklyn Bedding Products
Aside from mattresses, Avocado (left) and Brooklyn Bedding (right) sell beddings including pillows and blankets

Founded in 2016, Avocado has slowly built a reputation as a sustainable bed-in-a-box brand. The company uses natural materials and sustainable manufacturing in their products, such as wool, organic cotton, and natural latex. And while the Green Mattress is one of the best organic mattresses to buy, the company also sells other bedding accessories, including bed frames, pillows, and more.

Today, Avocado’s products are all certified by the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS). GOTS is the premiere ‘textile processing standard for organic fibers’. Avocado’s factories are also powered by renewable energy. They even run farms to produce their own latex. Both are examples of the brand’s commitment to sustainability.

On the other hand, Brooklyn Bedding was established in 1996, giving them the edge in experience. Based in Arizona, the brand sells a variety of mattress types, including memory foam, innerspring, and hybrid. However, their most popular product remains the customizable mattresses that come in different firmness levels.

Brooklyn Bedding is also known for their expansive product range. This is present across their catalog, which includes sheets, pillows, mattress protectors, and even adjustable bases.

Design and Construction

Avocado highlights the natural and eco-friendly construction of its mattress, while Brooklyn Bedding puts an emphasis on customizable firmness.

Avocado vs Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Design and Construction
A look at the Green Mattress’ innerspring unit (left) and the 13-inch thick Spring Hybrid Mattress (right)

While the flagship mattresses from Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding are both hybrid, there are key differences in their construction.

Avocado Green Mattress

Avocado’s Green Mattress comes in two variants. You can choose either the Standard or the Pillow-Top model. The standard Green Mattress measures 11 inches thick, while the pillow-top variant comes in at 13 inches. As its name implies, the pillow-top model features a two-inch European-style pillow-top made from organic latex rubber foam.

Both Green Mattress options have a 100% organic cotton cover. Below it is the top layer made from 100% natural Dunlop latex. To support the bed, Avocado’s Green Mattress also boasts an innerspring base layer made from over 1,000 individual tempered steel coils. Lastly, both standard and pillow-top variants feature needle-tufted rosettes on the outside.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress

In contrast, Brooklyn Bedding’s Signature Hybrid Mattress has five layers and is 11.5 inches tall. You can also get the bed in three firmness options — soft, medium, and firm. All variants follow the same type of construction but vary in the thickness of their layers.

For the Signature Hybrid Mattress, the comfort layer combines a quilted pillow top that contains the company’s proprietary TitanFlex foam and a layer of premium memory foam. Next, a layer of transitional VariFlex foam reinforces the comfort layers. It also serves as a buffer between a sleeper’s body and the base.

As a hybrid mattress, Brooklyn Bedding’s flagship bed boasts an eight-inch layer of up to 961 individually wrapped coils. And for added durability, the mattress adds a high-density base that reinforces the coils when they compress.

Firmness and Comfort

The Avocado Green Mattress is a firmer bed ideal for sleepers in need of support. Meanwhile, the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid Mattress is a plusher option that offers more pressure relief.

Avocado vs Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Firmness and Comfort
Both the Green Mattress (left) and the Signature Hybrid Mattress (right) have been recognized for their performance and value.

The standard Avocado Green Mattress is a 7 on the firmness scale, while the pillow-top option scores a 6. If you want a medium-firm bed, the standard variant is the way to go. Avocado says it’s ideal for back and stomach sleepers and taller side sleepers. Meanwhile, the pillow-top offers a plusher feel that bodes well for side and combination sleepers.

As mentioned in the Design section, Brooklyn Bedding’s Signature Hybrid Mattress is available in soft, medium, and firm options. On the firmness scale, the soft option scores a 3, the medium a 5, and the firm variant a 7. This means the Avocado Green Mattress is a firmer medium-firm bed than the Brooklyn Bedding mattress.

Heavier sleepers will find Avocado’s bed more supportive than Brooklyn Bedding. However, side sleepers might gravitate towards the softer variant of the Signature Hybrid Mattress. It offers more pressure relief by allowing the sleeper to sink deeper into the mattress. The soft and medium variants of the bed deliver gentler support to a body’s natural contours.

If you sleep hot, Avocado has a slight edge in temperature control. The Green Mattress uses latex, which doesn’t retain as much body heat as the memory foam on Signature Hybrid Mattress. Brooklyn Bedding does offer a solution, which is an optional cooling cover. Lastly, sleepers sensitive to allergens will find Avocado’s organic beds healthier.

Edge Support and Motion Isolation

Avocado’s Green Mattress offers better edge support, while Brooklyn Bedding’s Signature Hybrid Mattress wins in motion isolation.

Avocado vs Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Edge Support and Motion Isolation
Both the Avocado Green Mattress (left) and Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress (right) feature reinforced perimeters

A mattress with good edge support will allow you to sit comfortably on the edge without feeling like you’re going to slide off. It also makes it easier to get in and out of the bed, especially if you have mobility issues.

Here, the Avocado Green Mattress has the edge—no pun intended. The organic mattress has a fully reinforced steel perimeter for consistent support up to the edge. It’s also constructed with more innerspring coils for stability. Brooklyn Bedding’s Signature Hybrid Mattress features higher gauge coils along the perimeter. However, the mattress’s softer feel sinks sleepers deeper into the bed.

When it comes to motion isolation, this sinkage from the Signature Hybrid Mattress proves to be an advantage. Thanks to its slower-moving top layer, Brooklyn Bedding’s mattresses, particularly the soft and medium options, absorb isolation better. If you are sensitive to movement or share a bed with a partner, this is the bed to get.

Verdict

Get the Avocado mattress if you need a supportive, hypoallergenic mattress. Opt for the Brooklyn Bedding hybrid if you prefer a budget-friendly and contouring bed.

Although Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding’s flagship mattresses are hybrid types, they will cater to different consumers.

Avocado has built a reputation for organic products manufactured through sustainable means. The brand’s top-rated Avocado Green Mattress is ideal for sleepers who require a hypoallergenic and healthy bed. Made from latex, the bed retains less body heat, too. Avocado’s mattress works for those who want more support, too, thanks to its firmer feel.

If you want the feeling of being embraced by a mattress, go for the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress. The soft and medium variants, in particular, offer a plush feel that delivers the right amount of pressure relief for side sleepers. Light sleepers, as well as those who share a bed with a partner, will also like the strong motion isolation of the mattress.

FAQs

📌 Does Avocado offer free shipping in the US?

Yes. However, surcharges apply for Alaska and Hawaii.

📌 Does Brooklyn Bedding offer free shipping in the US?

Brooklyn Bedding offers free shipping to the contiguous US. Meanwhile, a $125 shipping fee applies to Alaska and Hawaii.

📌 How does Brooklyn Bedding deliver its mattress?

Brooklyn Bedding delivers the Signature Hybrid Mattress in a box.

📌 Is the wool used by Avocado OEKO-TEX certified?

Yes. Avocado shares that the its OEKO-TEX certified wool come from a farmer’s society they also co-own.

RELATED  Coway AP-1512HH vs Airmega 200M (2022): Comparing Air Purifiers from Coway
Mari Bassig

Senior Editor, writer and researcher passionate about gadgets, social media, and music.