We are reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

AeroGarden vs Gardyn (2021): Comparing Large Capacity Indoor Gardens

It’s always nice to harvest fresh herbs and vegetables from your kitchen. For novice green thumbs and seasoned gardeners, this convenience has been made possible by indoor hydroponic gardens. Many of these innovative systems are even compact enough to place on a kitchen countertop. But there are also large-capacity models for those who want bigger yields.

Gardyn is one of the top names in this area. Named as one of the best inventions of 2020, the tower-style garden can hold up to 30 plants and boasts a subscription system. But how does it fare against a tried-and-tested name like AeroGarden, particularly the company’s AeroGarden Farm 24XL? Below we compare the two large-capacity indoor gardens to find out.

AeroGarden vs Gardyn Comparison Chart

ModelAeroGarden Farm 24XLGardyn Home Kit
 Amazon productAmazon product
PriceAmazon productAmazon product
Capacity24 pods30 pods
Lighting System2x 60W LED2x 60W LED
Water Level AlertsYesYes
Plant Food AlertsYesYes
Dimmable LightsYesYes
Motorized Light PanelsYesNo
Wi-Fi ConnectivityYesYes
Mobile AppYesYes
CameraNoYes
Subscription PackageNoYes
Dimensions46 x 36 x 14 inches64 x 24 x 12 inches

Design and Capacity

The AeroGarden Farm 24XL has plants that grow from the base. Gardyn, on the other hand, uses vertical columns.

AeroGarden vs Gardyn Design and Capacity Review
AeroGarden’s Farm 24XL is a horizontal system (left) while the Gardyn is more like a tower (right).

AeroGarden’s Farm family offers the largest models in the brand’s catalog. In the lineup, the AeroGarden Farm 24XL is the biggest. At nearly four feet tall and three feet wide, the system is best set up on the floor. Like other gardens in the Farm family, however, the Farm 24XL follows a modular design. This means you can stack other Farm models on top of each other.

In terms of aesthetics, the Farm 24XL sports a sleek, industrial look. Although it comes with a matte finish, the garden’s sheer size still lends it a robust quality. The base of the garden follows other AeroGarden models, too. Here you’ll find the two growing decks side-by-side, each capable of handling 12 pods for a total capacity of 24 โ€” hence the 24XL moniker. An optional trellis system can also be attached.

The Gardyn, on the other hand, employs a vertical hydroponic system. Instead of a growing deck, three columns tower from its water tank. Each column has 10 pods, arranged alternately left and right for a total capacity of 30 plants. When assembled, the Gardyn is over five feet tall. To keep it stable, the garden comes with safety straps you can attach to a wall.

Both AeroGarden and Gardyn use two 60W LED systems. Because of its orientation, however, the Gardyn’s lights are also set up like posts facing the pod columns. Plants also tend to jut out as they grow. On the AeroGarden, the grow light systems hang from a hood. These lights are motorized so you can adjust their height as your plants flourish.

Features

AeroGarden has better built-in features, while Gardyn boasts a more comprehensive mobile app and customer support.

AeroGarden vs Gardyn Features Comparison
Here’s a look at the AeroGarden Farm 24XL in use (left) and Gardyn’s intuitive mobile app (right).

Like most indoor hydroponic systems, the AeroGarden Farm 24XL and Gardyn are automated. Both their water and light systems are already designed to follow a cycle. However, you can still adjust their schedules. This is especially useful for lighting. Given how bright the LED systems are, most users prefer the lights turned on only during the day.

To modify settings, the AeroGarden features a touch screen control panel. The component allows users to separately manage the left and right sides of the garden. It’s also where you can raise or lower the lights and adjust brightness. Gardyn also features dimmable lights and adjustable water schedules. Users can customize these settings via a mobile app instead of a control panel.

The Gardyn is also equipped with two 5MP cameras. Both take photos every 30 minutes. It’s a great way to check on your plant’s status remotely via the in-house Kelby smart assistant. If ever you need help with your Gardyn, the pictures also serve as a reference for customer support. If you’re not comfortable with the cameras, you can disable them through the mobile app.

AeroGarden also has a companion app, but not as comprehensive as Gardyn’s. It doesn’t come with a built-in smart assistant either. What it does offer is compatibility with other smart assistants. Thanks to Wi-Fi connectivity, the AeroGarden works with Alexa-enabled devices. This allows gardeners to adjust Farm 24XL settings and receive alerts remotely.

Ease of Use

Both the AeroGarden Farm 24XL and Gardyn are easy to manage and maintain.

AeroGarden vs Gardyn Ease of Use
LED lights can be lowered on the Farm 24XL (left); reaching for plants on Gardyn columns (right).

Unlike compact hydroponic gardens, the AeroGarden Farm 24XL and Gardyn require a more meticulous assembly. Because of their size, both systems come with several components. AeroGarden’s Farm 24XL, however, is easier to build. With Gardyn’s vertical orientation, there are a few more parts to consider. Hooking the water hoses and lights, for instance, can take some time. The stability of the garden also has to be ensured.

Nonetheless, growing and harvesting plants are pretty straightforward for both. Yes, these systems are automated, but there is still manual work involved. At the most, however, it will include refilling water tanks, adding plant food, or cleaning the machine.

With AeroGarden’s Farm 24XL, you can start your garden right out of the box by placing the pods on the grow deck. Gardyn, on the other hand, recommends sprouting the plants first in a separate container before moving them to the columns. The vertical orientation, however, provides adequate space between plants for more convenient harvesting.

To help novice gardeners, AeroGarden’s control panel displays the vital statistics of the garden. You can also view the information via the mobile app. Gardyn’s companion app also features tips and recommendations. But as mentioned in the Features section, you can get access to virtual and human customer support, too.

Seeds and Subscription

While AeroGarden offers more seed kit varieties, Gardyn provides a value-for-money membership package.

AeroGarden vs Gardyn Seeds and Subscriptions
A typical AeroGarden 24-Pod Salad Bar Kit (left) and Gardyn Sprout Nursery for up to 10 yCubes (right).

The AeroGarden Farm 24XL and Gardyn include a starting kit of seeds out of the box. AeroGarden typically offers a 24-pod selection of salad greens and herbs. There are also tomato and flowers kits available. Keep in mind, however, that these pods come at a maximum of 12 per package. So if you want to fill your Farm 24XL, you’ll need to get two of the 12-pod kits.

Custom options are also available but will be limited to a category. You can read more about this in our AeroGarden Harvest vs Harvest Elite review. All in all, you’ll have access to over 120 kinds of seed kits.

Meanwhile, Gardyn boasts a welcome kit of 30 plants or what it calls as yCubes. Here, customers can choose from four options. The Recommended Kit will include an assortment of plants and herbs to get you started. Farm Fresh 365 and Taste of Italy, on the other hand, are a curated kit of farmers’ market favorites and Italian flavors, respectively. There’s also an Immunity kit designed for the health-conscious.

If you want a steady supply of seeds, you can also sign up for a Gardyn membership. The subscription comes with 10 yCubes delivered every month. Additional yCubes are also cheaper with a membership. Plus, you get access to the Kelby smart assistant and expert support from plant experts. 

Verdict

Great customer support and membership packages give the Gardyn the slight edge. AeroGarden’s Farm 24XL, however, has access to more seed kit varieties.

Amazon product

The AeroGarden Farm 24XL is one of the best large-capacity indoor gardens to get. It’s easy to assemble, comes with enough smart features, and has access to an extensive catalog of plants. Gardyn, however, boasts a couple of pros that give it a slight edge. The towering garden, for instance, can hold more pods, 30 vs 24. Its mobile app is more intuitive than AeroGarden, too. With a membership, users even get access to a smart assistant and human customer support. If there’s any downside, however, it’s that you only get to choose from 50+ varieties of plants.

FAQs

๐Ÿ“Œ Does Gardyn offer purchase and membership options?

Gardyn is available as a standalone kit. If you want a membership, however, you can choose from two. There is the Gardyn Home Kit + One Year Membership and aGardyn Home Kit + Two Year Membership. You can check out your options here.

๐Ÿ“Œ Does Gardyn have a return policy?

Yes, Gardyn offers a 60-day return policy for its home kit.

๐Ÿ“Œ What is the allowable grow height for the AeroGarden Farm 24XL?

The AeroGarden Farm 24XL allows for a plant grow height of up to 36 inches.

๐Ÿ“Œ Does AeroGarden offer free shipping?

Yes, AeroGarden offers free shipping for orders above $50. This promotion, however, is only applicable within the contiguous United States.

RELATED  AeroGarden Bounty vs Bounty Basic vs Bounty Elite (2021): Which Indoor Garden Should You Get?
Avatar photo
Mari Bassig

Senior Editor, writer and researcher passionate about gadgets, social media, and music.